Former OnlyFans model Courtney Clenney resolved civil claims brought by Christian Obumseli’s family before her attorneys announced a plea agreement in the criminal case over his death. Clenney, 30, is charged with second-degree murder after Obumseli, 27, was fatally stabbed in their Miami apartment on April 3, 2022. The civil claims against Clenney were formally dismissed in March 2026, while claims against other defendants continued. The terms of the civil settlement and the proposed criminal plea remain undisclosed pending court action.
| 1) | Civil claims are settled and dismissed |
| 2) | Criminal plea agreement remains subject to approval |
| 3) | Competing accounts of the fatal stabbing |
| 4) | Timeline of the case and court proceedings |
| 5) | Unresolved questions surrounding the settlement |
Civil claims are settled and dismissed
The estate of Christian Obumseli filed a civil lawsuit several months after Courtney Clenney was arrested in August 2022. The case named Clenney as well as companies connected to the Miami condominium where the couple lived. Claims against Clenney included battery, while the estate alleged that the condominium association, property management and security defendants failed to provide adequate protection despite circumstances it said made the attack foreseeable.
On December 3, 2025, the estate filed a notice of settlement concerning Clenney alone. The claims against her were voluntarily dismissed with prejudice on March 4, 2026, meaning they cannot be brought again in the same form. The civil case continued against other defendants, and its resolution did not determine the outcome of the separate criminal prosecution.
Criminal plea agreement remains subject to approval
Clenney’s attorneys announced on July 31, 2026, that they had reached a plea agreement with prosecutors in the second-degree murder case. The agreement was scheduled to be presented to a judge on August 10, but defense attorneys said its terms would not become final unless the court accepted them.
Neither the defense nor prosecutors disclosed the proposed terms before the hearing. Clenney has remained in custody since her August 2022 arrest. The timing of the announcement placed the criminal plea negotiations after the civil claims against her had already been settled and dismissed, although the two proceedings are legally separate.
Competing accounts of the fatal stabbing
Clenney has not denied causing the fatal injury, but she has maintained that she acted in self-defense. Her attorneys have said that Christian Obumseli attacked her and that she threw a kitchen knife, which struck him in the chest. They have also portrayed Clenney as a battered partner and alleged that Obumseli had been abusive.
Obumseli’s family has rejected that characterization and has maintained that he was the victim of domestic violence. The criminal charge reflects prosecutors’ allegation that Clenney committed second-degree murder. At the time of her arrest, Miami-Dade State Attorney Katherine Fernandez Rundle described the relationship as a:
“tempestuous and combative relationship”
That competing evidence and the question of whether the stabbing was justified have been central to the criminal case.
Timeline of the case and court proceedings
Clenney and Obumseli were living together in a Miami apartment when he was fatally stabbed on April 3, 2022. Clenney was arrested in August 2022 and charged with second-degree murder. The civil lawsuit followed, naming Clenney and entities associated with the apartment property.
The estate notified the court of its settlement with Clenney on December 3, 2025. The court record then reflected the dismissal of the claims against her on March 4, 2026. That order came 10 days before the July 31 announcement of the criminal plea agreement. The agreement was expected to be reviewed by the court on August 10, 2026.
Unresolved questions surrounding the settlement
The public civil docket does not disclose how much, if anything, was paid under the settlement or what other conditions may have been included. It also does not resolve the allegations against the remaining civil defendants, whose cases continued after Clenney’s dismissal.
The proposed criminal plea likewise remained confidential before the scheduled hearing. A settlement in a civil case does not establish criminal responsibility, and the criminal case could proceed differently if the judge rejected the agreement. The court’s decision and any later filings will determine the next formal steps in the prosecution.
| Number | Key Point |
|---|---|
| 1) | Civil claims against Courtney Clenney were settled and dismissed with prejudice. |
| 2) | The settlement terms were not made public. |
| 3) | Clenney’s proposed criminal plea required judicial approval. |
| 4) | The defense claims self-defense, while Obumseli’s family disputes that account. |
Summary
Courtney Clenney’s civil dispute with Christian Obumseli’s estate ended before the public announcement of a proposed plea agreement in the criminal case. The civil settlement does not resolve the murder charge, and its undisclosed terms do not establish what may happen at the criminal hearing. The court’s acceptance or rejection of the plea agreement remains the next significant procedural development.
Frequently Asked Questions
What was Courtney Clenney charged with?
Clenney was charged with second-degree murder in connection with the April 3, 2022, stabbing death of Christian Obumseli in Miami.
What happened to the civil lawsuit?
The estate settled its claims against Clenney, and those claims were voluntarily dismissed with prejudice on March 4, 2026. The lawsuit continued against other defendants.
Was the criminal plea agreement final?
No. Clenney’s attorneys said the agreement would not become final unless it was presented to and accepted by the court.
Were the settlement terms disclosed?
No. The public civil docket did not disclose the terms of the settlement with Clenney.