Close Menu
News JournosNews Journos
  • World
  • U.S. News
  • Business
  • Politics
  • Europe News
  • Finance
  • Turkey Reports
  • Money Watch
  • Health
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
Latest Headlines:
  • Nvidia’s Jensen Huang Courts Beijing Amid Renewed Market Access in China
  • Volcanic Eruption in Iceland Forces Evacuation of Tourists from Blue Lagoon as Lava Approaches Grindavik
  • Humanity Faces Significant Losses, Says Spokesperson
  • Gun Seller Backed by Donald Trump Jr. Launches Stock Trading
  • Lightning Strike in New Jersey Leaves 1 Dead, 13 Injured
  • Used EV Batteries Poised to Power AI Growth
  • UK Inflation Data Reveals Key Trends for June
  • Hijacked Small Plane Grounds Flights at Vancouver International Airport
  • Experts Warn of Vulnerabilities in Federal E-Verify System Following Workplace Raids
  • Trial Commences Over Alleged Facebook Privacy Violations Involving CEO and Others
  • Controversy Surrounds Franco-Israeli Singer Amir at Francofolies de Spa Festival
  • Newsom Criticizes Trump’s National Guard Move, Urges Maturity
  • Potential Consequences of Trump’s Dismissal of Fed Chair Powell
  • Prince Harry Honors Diana’s Legacy by Advocating Against Landmines in Angola
  • Tsunami Warning Lowered to Advisory Following 7.2 Magnitude Earthquake near Alaska
  • Goldman Sachs Reports Q2 2025 Earnings Results
  • Rubio Calls Israeli Strike on Damascus a ‘Misunderstanding’ Amid Peace Efforts
  • Complete Skeleton of Medieval Knight Discovered Beneath Former Ice Cream Parlor in Poland
  • James Gunn Discusses “Superman”: Release Date, Character’s Immigrant Story, and Themes of Kindness
  • Assembly Discusses Olive Grove; Tanal’s Brief Action Sparks Varank’s Controversial Remarks
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
News JournosNews Journos
Subscribe
Tuesday, July 29
  • World
  • U.S. News
  • Business
  • Politics
  • Europe News
  • Finance
  • Turkey Reports
  • Money Watch
  • Health
News JournosNews Journos
European Court Rules 2019 Detention of Demirtaş Arbitrary

European Court Rules 2019 Detention of Demirtaş Arbitrary

Serdar ImrenBy Serdar ImrenJuly 8, 2025 Turkey Reports 6 Mins Read

In a significant ruling, the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) declared Turkey’s detention of Kurdish political leader Selahattin Demirtaş as arbitrary and politically motivated. This decision, announced on September 19, 2023, emphasizes that his prolonged detention is not only unjustifiable but also aimed at undermining political pluralism. The court ordered Turkey to pay damages to Demirtaş, marking another critical stance by the European body against Turkey’s handling of political dissent.

Article Subheadings
1) Overview of the Ruling
2) Context of Demirtaş’s Detention
3) Legal Implications of the Decision
4) Reactions to the ECtHR Ruling
5) Future of Political Dissent in Turkey

Overview of the Ruling

The block ruling by the ECtHR on September 19, 2023, has caught international attention for its thorough assessment of the circumstances surrounding Selahattin Demirtaş’s detention. The court analyzed the Turkish authorities’ actions, concluding that his pretrial detention lacks justification and primarily serves a political purpose. The ECtHR asserted that this ongoing detention is both arbitrary and unjust, underscoring several breaches of the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR).

Among the court’s findings, four specific rights violations stood out. The court pointed out that his prolonged detention—potentially extending to over four years—was not only excessive but also disproportionate to the charges. The lack of proper judicial oversight further signaled that Demirtaş’s rights, particularly the right to liberty, security, trial, and fair judicial review, were fundamentally compromised.

Context of Demirtaş’s Detention

Arrested in November 2016, Selahattin Demirtaş has emerged as a controversial figure within the context of Turkish politics. As a leader of the pro-Kurdish People’s Democratic Party (HDP), he has vocally opposed the ruling government and its policies towards the Kurdish population in Turkey. His apprehension was marked by allegations that he had been involved in promoting terrorism—a charge often levied against political figures whose sentiments clash with the state’s narratives.

The legal issues surrounding Demirtaş’s case moreover stem from accusations that the Turkish government is using the judiciary for political ends. Experts have often highlighted that his case underscores a broader pattern of suppressing dissent in Turkey, where opposition voices face increasing risks of legal action based solely on their viewpoints and political affiliations.

Legal Implications of the Decision

The ECtHR’s recent ruling not only demands that Turkey acknowledges the breaches of rights but also mandates compensation to Demirtaş. The court ordered the Turkish government to pay 35,000 euros in non-pecuniary damages and an additional 20,000 euros for legal costs incurred by Demirtaş. This financial liability adds another layer of complexity, revealing Turkey’s potential international legal ramifications if it continues to ignore the ECtHR’s rulings.

The legal implications extend further as this marks the second ruling against Turkey regarding Demirtaş’s detention. A previous ruling in 2018 found violations of Articles 5/3 and 18 of the ECHR, calling for his release—a demand that Turkey has so far resisted. Failure to comply with the court’s orders not only diminishes Turkey’s international standing but also raises questions about its commitment to human rights.

Reactions to the ECtHR Ruling

The recent ECtHR decision has been met with a mix of support and criticism both domestically and internationally. Rights activists and various political figures have hailed the ruling as a critical acknowledgment of the systemic issues in Turkey’s treatment of political dissent. Many consider it a victory for human rights, emphasizing that it reflects the court’s commitment to uphold democratic principles in the face of governmental overreach.

On the contrary, Turkish officials have downplayed the ruling, asserting that it is an interference in the country’s judicial processes. They argue that national security concerns justify Demirtaş’s ongoing detention, framing the ECtHR’s stance as an unwarranted criticism of Turkey’s sovereignty. This dichotomy reflects broader tensions between Turkey and European institutions regarding human rights and governance.

Future of Political Dissent in Turkey

The ECtHR’s ruling raises pressing questions about the future of political dissent in Turkey. As Selahattin Demirtaş continues to be a symbol of resistance against state oppression, the implications of this ruling could either embolden further dissent or heighten the government’s crackdown on opposition voices. Analysts suggest that the government may respond with harsher measures aimed at silencing critics, given the harsh political climate.

The eco-political landscape in Turkey remains fraught with uncertainty, and the trajectory for political spaces seems perilous. Whether Turkey chooses to adhere to such international rulings could significantly influence not only Demirtaş’s fate but also that of numerous political figures who face similar struggles against state repression.

No. Key Points
1 The ECtHR ruled Turkey’s detention of Selahattin Demirtaş as arbitrary and politically motivated.
2 Turkey has been ordered to pay damages to Demirtaş due to breaches of his rights.
3 The ruling highlights multiple violations of the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR).
4 This marks the second ruling from the ECtHR regarding Demirtaş’s detention.
5 The reaction to the ruling reflects the wider tensions between Turkey and European bodies.

Summary

The recent ruling from the European Court of Human Rights presents a critical examination of Turkey’s handling of political dissent exemplified by Selahattin Demirtaş‘s case. It highlights severe violations of human rights and underscores the ongoing struggle within Turkey concerning political freedoms. As the situation develops, both national and international reactions will play a significant role in determining the trajectory of political dissent and the government’s willingness to adhere to international law.

Frequently Asked Questions

Question: Who is Selahattin Demirtaş?

Selahattin Demirtaş is a Kurdish political leader and former co-chair of the pro-Kurdish People’s Democratic Party (HDP) in Turkey, known for his criticism of the Turkish government’s policies towards the Kurdish population.

Question: Why did the European Court of Human Rights issue a ruling against Turkey?

The ECtHR ruled against Turkey because it deemed Demirtaş’s detention arbitrary, politically motivated, and in violation of multiple articles of the European Convention on Human Rights.

Question: What are the implications of the ECtHR ruling for Turkey?

The ruling could result in increased scrutiny of Turkey’s human rights practices and put pressure on the government to comply with international norms, potentially affecting its political landscape and international relations.

Arbitrary Court Critical Issues in Turkey Demirtaş Democracy in Turkey detention Domestic Affairs Turkey Economic Policy Turkey European Government Policies Turkey Legislative Updates Turkey Media and Politics Turkey National Security Turkey Political Developments Turkey Political Reforms Turkey Regional Impact Turkey rules Social Issues Turkey Turkey’s Strategic Developments Turkish Diplomacy Turkish Elections Turkish Foreign Relations Turkish Leadership Turkish Legal Affairs Turkish Politics Turkish Public Policy
Serdar Imren
  • Website

Serdar Imren is a distinguished journalist with an extensive background as a News Director for major Turkish media outlets. His work has consistently focused on upholding the core principles of journalistic integrity: accuracy, impartiality, and a commitment to the truth. In response to the growing restrictions on press freedom in Turkey, he established News Journos to create a platform for independent and critical journalism. His reporting and analysis cover Turkish politics, human rights, and the challenges facing a free press in an increasingly authoritarian environment.

Keep Reading

Turkey Reports

Humanity Faces Significant Losses, Says Spokesperson

6 Mins Read
Turkey Reports

Assembly Discusses Olive Grove; Tanal’s Brief Action Sparks Varank’s Controversial Remarks

5 Mins Read
Turkey Reports

Mothers Reflect on PKK Weapon-Burning Ceremony: A Call for Peace

7 Mins Read
Turkey Reports

Özgür Özel Warns of Dream Disturbance: “A Nightmare Awaits”

5 Mins Read
Turkey Reports

İmamoğlu Receives 1-Year, 7-Month Prison Sentence for Remarks Against Chief Prosecutor

7 Mins Read
Turkey Reports

Prosecutor Tensions Emerge in Imamoglu Case Amid Controversy Over Evidence Access

5 Mins Read
Mr Serdar Avatar

Serdar Imren

News Director

Facebook Twitter Instagram
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram Pinterest
  • About Us
  • Get In Touch
  • Privacy Policy
  • Accessibility
  • Terms and Conditions
© 2025 The News Journos. Designed by The News Journos.

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.