A 20-year-old former California college swimmer has been charged in the death of a security guard at a resort in Lahaina, Maui, authorities said. Police allege that the suspect, Legend Storer, was unclothed when he approached the guard’s office during an overnight shift on Aug. 5, 2026. The guard, Michael Dyer, 63, was later found unresponsive and pronounced dead at the scene. Storer pleaded not guilty and remains held without bail as the investigation continues.
The incident began shortly before 2 a.m. at a condominium resort on Lower Honoapiʻilani Road. Investigators said surveillance footage connected a man seen at the resort with a 20-year-old who was later found wandering unclothed in a nearby Kahana neighborhood. Court records identify Storer as the person charged with second-degree murder, first-degree burglary involving a dangerous instrument and indecent exposure.
Police have not publicly released a detailed account of the alleged assault or identified the dangerous instrument referenced in the burglary charge. Prosecutors asked the court to keep Storer in custody without bail, while his attorney sought nominal bail. The request for bail was denied at his initial court appearance.
| Article Subheadings | |
|---|---|
| 1) | Overnight attack at Lahaina resort |
| 2) | Police response and identification of the suspect |
| 3) | Charges, court proceedings and detention |
| 4) | Victim’s work and family background |
| 5) | Suspect’s Hawaii and swimming background |
Overnight attack at Lahaina resort
According to the Maui Police Department, surveillance footage showed an unclothed man approaching Michael Dyer’s office at a condominium resort on Lower Honoapiʻilani Road in Lahaina at about 1:45 a.m. on Aug. 5. Police allege that the man assaulted Dyer before leaving the area on foot. Dyer was working an overnight security shift at Sands of Kahana, where he was responsible for security duties during the early morning hours.
At 5:31 a.m., officers were called back to the resort after Dyer was found unresponsive. He was pronounced dead at the scene. The available records describe the death as connected to an alleged attack, but authorities have not publicly provided a complete account of the injuries or released additional details about the circumstances inside the office.
Police response and identification of the suspect
A separate call came in at about 3:02 a.m. reporting that a naked man was walking through a neighborhood in nearby Kahana. Officers located a 20-year-old man at approximately 3:35 a.m. and found that he had numerous abrasions. He was taken to Maui Memorial Medical Center for evaluation.
Investigators later reviewed surveillance footage and determined that the man found in Kahana was the same person seen at the resort, police said. The department did not initially release the suspect’s name, citing a Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals ruling and its policy regarding the routine release of identifying information after an arrest. Hawaii court records later identified Storer as the defendant in the case.
Charges, court proceedings and detention
Storer faces charges of second-degree murder, first-degree burglary involving a dangerous instrument and indecent exposure. The written criminal complaint was filed Aug. 7, two days after the alleged killing. The charges remain allegations, and Storer pleaded not guilty during the initial court proceedings.
Prosecutors successfully requested that Storer be held without bail. His attorney asked for nominal bail, but the court denied that request. The case remains under investigation, and the available court records do not establish a final determination of guilt. Authorities have not announced a trial date or provided a public explanation of the alleged motive.
Victim’s work and family background
Michael Dyer was 63 and worked as a security guard at Sands of Kahana, according to information shared by family and friends. A fundraiser organized for the family of his wife, Joy Dyer, said the couple had been married for 26 years.
The fundraiser described the death as a devastating loss for Dyer’s family and community. No additional personal details about his employment history or the circumstances of his death were included in the available account. Authorities continue to gather evidence and review the events leading up to the fatal encounter.
Suspect’s Hawaii and swimming background
Legend Storer is a Lahaina native who graduated from Maui Preparatory Academy in 2024, according to an athletics profile. He was listed as a freshman breaststroke and sprint swimmer on Concordia University Irvine’s 2024-25 men’s swimming and diving roster and was described as a two-time Maui Interscholastic League winner.
The available information indicates that Storer later transferred out of Concordia. His attorneys, Brandon Michael Segal and Myles S. Breiner, were contacted for comment, as was the university. The case is pending, and no response from them was included in the report.
| Number | Key Point |
|---|---|
| 1 | A Lahaina resort security guard was found dead after an alleged overnight attack. |
| 2 | Police linked surveillance footage to a 20-year-old man later found in nearby Kahana. |
| 3 | Storer pleaded not guilty to murder, burglary and indecent exposure charges. |
| 4 | The court ordered Storer held without bail while the investigation continues. |
Summary
The Maui case involves the alleged fatal assault of resort security guard Michael Dyer during an overnight shift and the arrest of Legend Storer after police connected him to surveillance footage from the property. Storer has pleaded not guilty, and the prosecution must still prove the charges in court. Investigators have not disclosed a motive or all details of the alleged attack.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who was killed in the Maui resort incident?
Michael Dyer, 63, was a security guard working an overnight shift at Sands of Kahana in Lahaina. He was found unresponsive and pronounced dead at the resort.
What charges does Legend Storer face?
Legend Storer faces second-degree murder, first-degree burglary involving a dangerous instrument and indecent exposure charges. He pleaded not guilty.
Why was the suspect held without bail?
Prosecutors requested detention without bail at Storer’s initial court appearance. The court denied his attorney’s request for nominal bail. The specific reasoning for the detention decision was not detailed in the available account.
