Desmond Carter, one of several men charged in connection with the alleged rape of LSU student Madison Brooks, is seeking to keep text messages out of his December trial. The messages describe warnings from Carter’s mother not to speak with police after Brooks was allegedly assaulted in 2023. Brooks was later struck and killed by a vehicle after leaving the group. A judge has not yet ruled on whether the messages may be introduced as evidence.
| 1) | The charges and December trial |
| 2) | What the text messages describe |
| 3) | The defense challenge and court decision |
| 4) | Accounts of the night and investigation |
| 5) | The broader courtroom dispute |
The charges and December trial
Desmond Carter, 21, has pleaded not guilty to first-degree and third-degree rape charges. His trial is scheduled to begin December 7 in Louisiana. The charges stem from an incident involving Madison Brooks, a 19-year-old LSU student who was allegedly assaulted after a night out near the Baton Rouge campus in January 2023.
The case involves several defendants. Kaivon Washington and Carter maintain that their sexual encounters with Brooks were consensual. Casen Carver has pleaded not guilty to charges of principal to rape and video voyeurism. Prosecutors allege that Carver drove the vehicle in which the alleged assault occurred and recorded the encounter.
What the text messages describe
Court documents show a series of messages exchanged among Carter and co-defendants after the alleged assault. In the messages, Carter repeatedly referred to instructions from his mother not to speak with investigators or go to a police station. He also indicated that she would not allow officers to question him unless he had been charged.
The messages also refer to concerns that the men could be treated as witnesses and to the disclosure of their names by Carver. The court filing does not identify the recipient of each individual message, leaving the precise sequence and audience of some exchanges unclear.
The defense challenge and court decision
Carter’s attorney asked the court to exclude the messages in a filing submitted in September. The defense argues that using the communications as evidence would violate Carter’s Fifth Amendment protection against self-incrimination.
Judge Gail Horne Ray has not ruled on the request. The decision will determine whether prosecutors can use the messages to address the defendants’ conduct and communications after the alleged assault. It will also establish how the jury may hear about Carter’s reported discussions concerning contact with police.
Accounts of the night and investigation
According to accounts given to police, the men said Brooks asked to be taken home after the encounter. They said she supplied several incorrect addresses before asking to be dropped near a subdivision, where they reported that she wandered into the roadway and was hit by a car.
Brooks died after being struck. Her blood alcohol concentration was reported as 0.319%, nearly four times Louisiana’s legal driving limit for adults who are at least 21. The driver remained at the scene and was ultimately cleared of charges. Prosecutors and defense attorneys dispute the meaning of the events leading to Brooks’ death and the alleged sexual encounter.
The broader courtroom dispute
The evidence dispute comes as the case has drawn attention from Brooks’ family and supporters. Carter’s defense has also sought to restrict spectators from wearing pink during the trial, arguing that coordinated clothing could influence jurors. Pink has become associated with public support for Brooks.
Brooks’ mother, Ashley Baustert, has opposed that effort and said her daughter believed she was safe with the men that night. The judge’s rulings on courtroom attire and the text messages will shape the proceedings, but neither issue determines the defendants’ guilt or innocence.
| 1 | Carter has pleaded not guilty, and his trial is scheduled for December 7. |
| 2 | The messages describe warnings not to speak with police after the alleged assault. |
| 3 | The defense says admitting the messages would raise Fifth Amendment concerns. |
| 4 | The driver who struck Brooks remained at the scene and was cleared of charges. |
| 5 | A judge has not yet ruled on the text-message evidence or courtroom attire dispute. |
Summary
The December trial will address allegations surrounding the sexual assault of Madison Brooks, while the court must first resolve whether messages about avoiding police contact can be admitted. The defendants have denied wrongdoing or asserted that the encounters were consensual. The pending evidentiary and courtroom rulings will define the scope of the proceedings, but the jury will ultimately determine the criminal charges against the defendants.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who is Desmond Carter?
Desmond Carter is a 21-year-old defendant charged with first-degree and third-degree rape in connection with the alleged assault of Madison Brooks.
What do the disputed messages concern?
They concern warnings attributed to Carter’s mother telling him not to speak with police after the alleged assault.
When is the trial scheduled?
Carter’s trial is scheduled to begin December 7 in Louisiana.
Has the judge ruled on the messages?
No. Judge Gail Horne Ray has not yet issued a ruling on whether the messages may be used as evidence.

