A mother and her son helped federal investigators locate missing Utah teenager Kylie Arellano after communicating with her through the video game Among Us. Arellano disappeared from Garden City, Utah, in May 2025, when she was 15. The FBI later found her safe in Huntington, Oregon, and took 39-year-old Adam Hunter Harmel into custody. Authorities allege that Harmel held the girl against her will and subjected her to violence and sexual abuse.
The investigation gained momentum after a Colorado teenager and his mother, Khristina Tresp, spoke online with a female player who identified herself as Arellano. Tresp then used information provided during the conversation, along with publicly available photographs of homes, to help identify the location where the girl was allegedly being held.
The case illustrates how an online gaming interaction led to a family alerting authorities, conducting preliminary location research and ultimately connecting federal investigators with a possible site in another state.
| 1) | The disappearance of Kylie Arellano |
| 2) | A warning through Among Us |
| 3) | Matching homes to locate the teen |
| 4) | Allegations against the suspect |
| 5) | Federal investigators secure a breakthrough |
The disappearance of Kylie Arellano
Kylie Arellano was reported missing after disappearing from Garden City, Utah, in May 2025. She was 15 at the time. Her disappearance prompted a search that continued for approximately 18 months, eventually leading investigators hundreds of miles from Utah to Huntington, Oregon.
The case involved authorities in more than one state because Arellano was ultimately located in Oregon. The FBI became involved as investigators worked to determine where the missing teenager was and whether she was being held against her will.
A warning through Among Us
The breakthrough began when a Colorado teenager and his mother, Khristina Tresp, communicated with a female user while playing Among Us. The user said she was a runaway and was being held against her will by an older man who was hurting her, according to reported details of the investigation.
The family treated the conversation as an emergency and alerted authorities. The information provided by the player allowed Tresp to continue gathering details while officials assessed the report. The interaction was significant because it created a direct line of communication with someone believed to be the missing girl.
She was a runaway and being held against her will by a man that was older than her and was hurting her.
Matching homes to locate the teen
Khristina Tresp used information sent by the player to search for a possible location. She collected photographs of homes available online and sent a series of images to Arellano, using the girl’s responses to eliminate locations and identify a match.
That process connected the online conversation to a physical address or area in Oregon. Tresp then contacted Arellano’s mother the following day. The FBI also contacted Tresp, according to accounts of the investigation, allowing federal authorities to pursue the lead directly.
The home-matching effort did not replace official investigative work, but it gave authorities a specific location to examine. The resulting lead helped move the case from an online report to an in-person law enforcement response.
Allegations against the suspect
A federal criminal complaint alleges that Adam Hunter Harmel, 39, kept Arellano in a residence in Huntington, Oregon. The complaint alleges that he forced the victim to sleep in the same bed, kept a knife under his pillow and made her sleep against a wall to make escape more difficult.
The complaint also alleges that Harmel sexually assaulted the victim and became violent and aggressive, including allegedly hitting her. Other reported allegations state that the girl was held in a basement and was forced to remove her braces with pliers. These claims remain allegations in a criminal case, and Harmel is presumed innocent unless proven guilty in court.
Federal investigators secure a breakthrough
The FBI found Kylie Arellano in Oregon after the information developed through the video game conversation and Tresp’s home-photo comparison. Arellano was found safe, while Adam Hunter Harmel was taken into custody.
The case demonstrates how information from an online platform can become useful to investigators when it is reported quickly and supported with additional details. The Colorado family’s actions helped authorities identify a possible location, while federal agents handled the recovery and criminal investigation.
| Number | Key Point |
|---|---|
| 1 | Arellano disappeared from Utah in May 2025 at age 15. |
| 2 | A Colorado mother and son communicated with her through Among Us. |
| 3 | Online home photographs helped identify a possible location in Oregon. |
| 4 | The FBI found Arellano in Huntington, Oregon, after the extended search. |
| 5 | A federal complaint alleges confinement, violence and sexual assault by Harmel. |
Summary
A gaming conversation provided the initial warning that led a Colorado mother and son to contact authorities about a missing Utah teenager. Their follow-up effort to match online home photographs helped federal investigators focus on Oregon, where Arellano was found safe and Harmel was taken into custody. The allegations against Harmel are set out in a federal criminal complaint and have not been proven in court.
Frequently Asked Questions
How was Kylie Arellano located?
She was located in Huntington, Oregon, after a Colorado mother and her son communicated with her through Among Us and helped identify a possible home using photographs found online.
Who was taken into custody?
Adam Hunter Harmel, 39, was taken into custody after the FBI found Arellano in Oregon.
What do investigators allege happened to Arellano?
A federal criminal complaint alleges that she was held against her will, subjected to violence and sexual assault, and prevented from escaping. The allegations have not been tested at trial.
When did Arellano disappear?
She disappeared from Garden City, Utah, in May 2025, when she was 15 years old.

