Susan Smith is scheduled to appear before a seven-member parole board in Columbia, South Carolina, as she seeks release after more than 30 years in prison. She was convicted in 1995 of murdering her two young sons, Michael and Alexander, by allowing her car to roll into a lake. Prosecutor Tommy Pope says her release could bring unwanted public attention into the daily life of the boys’ father, David Smith. Pope and David Smith oppose parole and say Smith should remain imprisoned.
The hearing follows Smith’s first parole denial in November 2024. Under South Carolina law in effect when she was sentenced, her life sentence allowed her to seek parole after serving 30 years.
Article Subheadings
| 1) | The parole hearing and legal timeline |
| 2) | The 1994 killings and false carjacking account |
| 3) | Why the prosecutor opposes Smith’s release |
| 4) | The father’s position and continuing grief |
| 5) | Smith’s previous parole arguments |
The parole hearing and legal timeline
The South Carolina parole board is expected to consider Smith’s case on Thursday morning in Columbia. The seven-member panel will decide whether she should be released after she became eligible under the law that governed her 1995 life sentence. Smith’s first parole request was rejected in November 2024, making the upcoming proceeding another opportunity for the board to review her conduct, statements and suitability for release.
Pope, who prosecuted the case and now serves as speaker pro tempore of the South Carolina House of Representatives, has said he plans to attend every parole hearing. His stated purpose is to oppose release and support the position that Smith should remain in prison.
The 1994 killings and false carjacking account
Smith’s sons, 3-year-old Michael and 14-month-old Alexander, died on October 25, 1994. Prosecutors argued that Smith strapped the children into her car and allowed it to enter a lake as part of an effort to regain the attention of a former lover who did not want children.
After the killings, Smith initially told police that a Black man had carjacked her and taken the boys. David Smith, then her husband, believed the account. The couple appeared together on television to ask for help locating the children before investigators determined that Smith’s account was false and charged her in the boys’ deaths.
Why the prosecutor opposes Smith’s release
Pope says he fears Smith would actively seek public attention through social media if released. He believes that renewed attention could repeatedly confront David Smith with the person convicted of killing his sons, creating an ongoing source of distress rather than allowing him to grieve privately.
“It would be in David’s face every day, and all he has ever talked about is justice for Michael and Alex.”
Pope also questions the nature of Smith’s remorse. In his view, the jury intended the life sentence to mean that she would spend the rest of her life reflecting on the deaths. He has said Smith’s regret appears focused more on her own circumstances than on the harm suffered by the children.
The father’s position and continuing grief
David Smith has continued to seek justice for Michael and Alexander. Pope said David Smith has avoided vindictive language toward his former wife for religious reasons and has said he has forgiven her. At the same time, he believes the punishment should continue because of what happened to the boys.
The dispute over parole therefore involves both the legal question of whether Smith can be released and the personal consequences for the children’s surviving family. Pope says he will continue appearing alongside David Smith at hearings, which are expected to occur every two years if Smith remains eligible to seek parole.
Smith’s previous parole arguments
During her 2024 hearing, Smith appeared by video and expressed regret for killing her sons. She told the board that she understood the seriousness of her conduct and wished she could change what happened. She also said that she loved Michael and Alexander and described her Christian faith as an important part of her life.
“I know that what I did was horrible. And I would give anything if I could go back and change it.”
The board nevertheless denied parole at that hearing. The new proceeding will again place Smith’s statements and prison record before the panel, while Pope and David Smith present arguments for keeping her incarcerated.
Key Points
| No. | Key Point |
|---|---|
| 1 | Smith was convicted in 1995 and sentenced to life in prison. |
| 2 | Her sons died on October 25, 1994, after her car entered a lake. |
| 3 | A seven-member South Carolina board will decide her parole request. |
| 4 | Pope says release could expose David Smith to constant public attention. |
| 5 | Smith was denied parole at her first hearing in November 2024. |
Summary
Susan Smith’s parole hearing will revisit the sentence imposed for the deaths of her two sons. Prosecutor Tommy Pope and their father, David Smith, oppose her release, citing the seriousness of the crimes, their concerns about her remorse and the potential emotional impact of renewed public attention. The parole board’s decision will determine whether Smith remains in prison or becomes eligible for release under the law applicable to her case.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who is deciding Susan Smith’s parole request?
A seven-member South Carolina parole board in Columbia is scheduled to decide whether Smith should be released.
Why does Tommy Pope oppose her release?
Pope says Smith could embrace social media attention after release, potentially placing renewed public scrutiny and emotional distress in front of David Smith.
When was Smith previously denied parole?
Smith was denied parole at her first hearing in November 2024, when she appeared by video and expressed regret for the killings.
Why was Smith eligible to seek parole?
Although she received a life sentence in 1995, South Carolina law at that time allowed her to be considered for parole after serving 30 years.

