Two South Carolina men face murder charges in the 2023 road rage shooting death of North Carolina insurance adjuster Scott Spivey. Charles “Weldon” Boyd and Kenneth “Bradley” Williams initially said they acted in self-defense under South Carolina’s stand your ground law. Phone recordings later uncovered by Spivey’s sister became central to the family’s challenge of that account. Two former Horry County police officers also face allegations tied to the investigation.
Spivey was killed on Sept. 9, 2023, after a vehicle pursuit on Highway 9 in Horry County ended on Camp Swamp Road. A special prosecutor is handling the criminal case because local prosecutors had previously declined to file charges. All four defendants appeared in criminal court, but the judge did not immediately rule on bond requests.
| 1) | The shooting and the original self-defense claim |
|---|---|
| 2) | Recordings challenge the account of the confrontation |
| 3) | Former officers face investigation-related charges |
| 4) | Indictments follow a prolonged civil court fight |
| 5) | Family members reject the justification |
The shooting and the original self-defense claim
Scott Spivey, 33, was killed in Horry County on Sept. 9, 2023. Court documents state that Spivey, Boyd and Williams were armed during the encounter. The incident began with a vehicle chase on Highway 9 and ended about nine miles away on Camp Swamp Road in the Loris area.
The defense account says Spivey pointed a pistol at Williams and forced Boyd’s truck off the road. Boyd told a 911 dispatcher that the other driver had fired first. Boyd and Williams invoked South Carolina’s stand your ground law, arguing that they were protecting themselves from an irrational driver.
The family’s account differs. Court filings say Spivey eventually stopped, left his vehicle and shouted at the men to stop following him. A wrongful death complaint alleges that Boyd and Williams then opened fire.
Recordings challenge the account of the confrontation
Jennifer Spivey Foley, Spivey’s sister, found recordings from Boyd’s phone in the police case file. The recordings had not previously been made public or considered in the case. According to court documents filed in the wrongful death lawsuit, Boyd remained on the phone with a 911 dispatcher until the shooting occurred.
The civil complaint alleges that Boyd said Spivey was trying to get away while also indicating that he was prepared for a confrontation. The recordings also reportedly show Boyd later calling a friend who was the Horry County deputy police chief at the time. Circuit Court Judge Eugene Griffith ruled that the secretly recorded calls indicated Boyd was seeking law enforcement assistance and attempting to avoid responsibility.
Former officers face investigation-related charges
Brandon Strickland and Paul Vescovi, both former members of the Horry County Police Department, face charges connected to the investigation. The allegations include misconduct in office and obstruction of justice. Strickland, who allegedly spoke with Boyd after the shooting, was additionally charged with criminal conspiracy.
The allegations have placed the handling of the original investigation under scrutiny. The case is being prosecuted by a special prosecutor because local prosecutors previously declined to bring criminal charges. The available court reporting does not establish the final outcome of the allegations against either former officer.
All four defendants appeared in criminal court on Thursday afternoon. The judge did not decide their bond requests at the end of the approximately two-hour hearing, and a ruling was expected to be posted later.
Indictments follow a prolonged civil court fight
Boyd and Williams were arrested more than three years after the shooting after a grand jury indicted them. Their lawyers had sought a stay of proceedings in the family’s civil wrongful death lawsuit on Nov. 5, citing a pending grand jury inquiry. The indictments followed within days.
Filed in 2024, the civil lawsuit became the setting for disputes over the phone recordings and the competing accounts of the shooting. The criminal case is separate, and prosecutors must prove the allegations beyond a reasonable doubt. The attorneys representing Boyd and Williams were contacted for comment, but the available report did not include a response.
Family members reject the justification
Deborah Spivey, Scott Spivey’s mother, and Foley have rejected the argument that the shooting was protected by the stand your ground law. Foley attended the bond hearing and asked the judge to deny bond for Boyd and Williams. She also requested a mental health evaluation for Boyd.
The family has focused on the allegation that Spivey was followed for nearly 10 miles before the fatal encounter. Their attorney, Mark Tinsley, said the relatives had spent more than three years seeking an explanation for how and why Spivey died. The new indictments and misconduct allegations mark a significant shift, but all charges remain allegations until resolved in court.
| Number | Key Point |
|---|---|
| 1 | Boyd and Williams were indicted on murder charges in Spivey’s 2023 death. |
| 2 | Phone recordings uncovered by Foley challenged the self-defense account. |
| 3 | Two former Horry County officers face misconduct-related allegations. |
| 4 | Bond decisions were not issued immediately after the initial hearing. |
Summary
The murder indictments reopen the circumstances of Spivey’s death and challenge the original stand your ground defense. The phone recordings, the family’s civil lawsuit and allegations involving former officers have shifted the case toward a broader criminal investigation. Boyd, Williams, Strickland and Vescovi remain entitled to due process, and the courts will determine whether the evidence supports the charges.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who was killed in the shooting?
Scott Spivey, a 33-year-old insurance adjuster from North Carolina, was killed on Sept. 9, 2023, in Horry County, South Carolina.
Who faces murder charges?
Charles “Weldon” Boyd and Kenneth “Bradley” Williams were indicted and arrested on murder charges more than three years after the shooting.
What evidence challenged the self-defense claim?
Phone recordings from Boyd’s device, uncovered by Foley, reportedly captured conversations with a 911 dispatcher before and during the shooting and later contact with a former deputy police chief.
What charges do the former officers face?
Brandon Strickland and Paul Vescovi face allegations including misconduct in office and obstruction of justice. Strickland also faces a criminal conspiracy charge.

