Twenty-nine California district attorneys, victims’ families and law enforcement groups have sued Gov. Gavin Newsom over his plan to commute the sentences of 548 death row inmates. The lawsuit, filed Monday, argues that the governor acted without providing legally required notice and improperly bypassed established clemency procedures. The case comes with roughly 60 days remaining in Newsom’s term and has drawn national attention from federal officials and victims’ advocates.
The petition was filed on behalf of prosecutors from half of California’s 58 counties and families connected to more than two dozen murder victims. It challenges both the scope of the proposed clemency and the process used to advance it.
| 1) | Prosecutors challenge Newsom’s mass clemency plan |
|---|---|
| 2) | Victims’ families describe the consequences |
| 3) | California’s death penalty remains legally active |
| 4) | The lawsuit raises notice and review questions |
| 5) | Legal experts question the challenge’s prospects |
Prosecutors challenge Newsom’s mass clemency plan
The Criminal Justice Legal Foundation is leading the lawsuit for 29 district attorneys, victims’ relatives and law enforcement organizations. Former Sacramento District Attorney Anne Marie Schubert, who heads the foundation, said the governor’s late-term action disregarded statutory requirements and interfered with the state Supreme Court’s role in reviewing certain cases.
“Only this Court can stop the Governor’s disregard of the law, his abuse of power,” Schubert wrote in the 58-page petition.
The challenge targets Newsom’s plan to commute every sentence on California’s death row. Prosecutors argue that the blanket approach overrides the work of juries, judges and local prosecutors who handled the convictions and penalties.
Victims’ families describe the consequences
Among the petitioners is Marc Klaas, whose 12-year-old daughter, Polly Klaas, was kidnapped from a slumber party in 1993 and strangled. Her convicted killer, Richard Allen Davis, has been on death row since 1996.
Other families connected to the case include relatives of eight-year-old Gabriel Fernandez, Placer County Sheriff’s Detective Mike Davis, Pittsburg Police Officer Larry Lasater, Sacramento Deputy Danny Paul Oliver and five U.S. Forest Service firefighters killed while battling the 40,000-acre Esperanza Fire in 2006. The petition argues that these families face a particularly severe impact because they were not given the notice they expected before the clemency action.
“The Governor’s assurance that the perpetrators will never be released is obviously cruelly false,” Schubert wrote.
California’s death penalty remains legally active
California has not carried out an execution in 20 years, despite having the largest death row in the United States. The death penalty remains part of state law, although Newsom has maintained that California cannot morally carry out executions.
Newsom has argued that the inmates affected by his plan would not qualify for other criminal justice reforms that could lead to additional sentence reductions or release. Gov.-elect Xavier Becerra is expected to continue the state’s execution moratorium after taking office. Critics, including Orange County District Attorney Todd Spitzer, say removing death sentences could nevertheless move condemned inmates closer to future leniency.
The lawsuit raises notice and review questions
The California Supreme Court is expected to review at least 382 inmates convicted of multiple felony offenses before the commutations become official. The petition contends that additional prisoners who meet the review criteria may not yet have been identified and that the administration could have relied on incomplete criminal records when assembling the list.
The prosecutors also dispute whether victims’ rights protections apply when a governor acts without a formal clemency application. Those protections generally provide advance information about certain clemency and parole decisions. The filing argues that allowing the absence of an application to eliminate notice requirements would leave the most sweeping actions outside ordinary oversight.
Legal experts question the challenge’s prospects
Los Angeles trial attorney and former federal prosecutor Neama Rahmani said the lawsuit faces substantial obstacles because governors traditionally have broad authority to commute sentences and issue pardons. He also questioned whether California’s victims’ rights law applies directly to the proposed commutations.
The dispute has also drawn the attention of federal officials. President Donald Trump, Attorney General Todd Blanche and FBI Director Kash Patel were expected to meet Monday with some victims’ families. White House spokeswoman Lauren Bis accused Newsom of failing victims and politicizing public safety, while Newsom’s office had not immediately responded to the lawsuit.
| Number | Key Point |
|---|---|
| 1 | Twenty-nine district attorneys joined the lawsuit. |
| 2 | Newsom plans to commute 548 death sentences. |
| 3 | Victims’ families allege they were denied required notice. |
| 4 | The state Supreme Court may review at least 382 cases. |
| 5 | Legal experts say the governor’s clemency authority may be broad. |
Summary
The lawsuit places Newsom’s proposed mass commutations at the intersection of executive clemency authority, victims’ rights and judicial review. Prosecutors and families argue that the governor bypassed required safeguards, while legal experts say the state constitution may give him broad discretion. The California Supreme Court’s review and the handling of notice requirements will be central to the dispute.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who filed the lawsuit?
The lawsuit was filed on behalf of 29 California district attorneys, victims’ families and law enforcement groups, with the Criminal Justice Legal Foundation coordinating the case.
How many death row sentences are covered by Newsom’s plan?
The plan would commute the sentences of 548 inmates on California’s death row.
What happens next?
The California Supreme Court is expected to review at least 382 cases before the proposed commutations become official, while the courts will consider the claims about notice, statutory procedures and executive authority.

